In Chuck Klosterman’s most recent book of semi-related essays, I Wear the Black Hat: Grappling with Villains, he defines villainy as the act of a person who knows the most but cares the least. Klosterman argues that knowledge of doing something malevolent and going through with it, regardless, is the root of evil. For without this knowledge, the actor can be declared unknowing or innocent.
While some of the villains on this list “maintain their innocence”, it can have a knack of implicating the individual further. Denying an act in some cases only proves the person cared so little that they neglected the collective feelings of the public, and only in order to serve themselves. On the other hand, why would denying make them more evil? Wouldn’t admitting to their “crime” prove how little they care?
“Hey look, I cheated, but we won, and it was worth it.”
The catch, however, is that if athletes admitted their wrongdoings, they would be seriously jeopardizing their careers; they must maintain their innocence in order to keep playing/winning/cheating. Thus, in keeping with Klosterman’s parameters, evil athletes don’t care that they gain an unfair advantage (at least for the ones that cheat), but care about winning and/or being successful so much that they can’t come clean.
Over the last 14 years, American sports has had its fair share of players, athletes and coaches who have embraced the “role” of the villain, even if they were labeled inappropriately. For the purposes of this exercise, we are also going to include them, simply because its extremely comical in some cases (we’ll arrive on that point later). In a way, this prototype of villain is similar to the actual concept of Klosterman’s, because the person knows they are hated, and they simply don’t care.
Regardless of how you want to classify it, it’s simply fun to root against some people in the Twitter-24-Hour-News-Cycle Era. Without further adieu, we give you the “best” villains since the year 2000.
Lance Armstrong
Sir Lance may very well be the poster child for this piece, for he achieved high status in his field of sport, American popular culture, and the business/philanthropy world. And those yellow bracelets. All of this of course was based on a lie. Perhaps the most undervalued aspect of Lance’s villainy is that in a way, he toyed with the public by gaining so much support over the fact that he survived–and beat–cancer. Not only did Lance Armstrong become the most successful cyclist of all time (winning seven consecutive Tour de France’s), he also created a foundation that raised over $400 million for cancer research, creating a billion dollar enterprise in the process.
Here’s the problem with what Lance did: he parlayed his miraculous fight with cancer (which no one can ever take away from him, and is by far his greatest accomplishment) with the prospect that he was able to maintain exceptional shape and become one of the world’s most elite athletes. Lance inspired hope in everyone who has ever been diagnosed or known someone with cancer, but in doing so he raised the public’s level of hope and belief to an unattainable degree. Lance Armstrong was a great athlete, but he wasn’t that great. He is a villain because he based his entire life’s cause on the premise that he was that great. Lance wasn’t saying “I beat cancer, and now I’m living a happy, successful life”, he was saying “I beat cancer, and now I’m The Greatest”.
This type of false message is wildly unethical because it produced large sums of money for accomplishments that were tainted by strict, explicit anti-blood doping laws in the sport of professional cycling. Niccolo Machiavelli may argue that there was an end to justify a mean (Armstrong’s ability to raise awareness and money for cancer is the worthiest of causes), but I find it hard to believe that Armstrong selflessly kept his lie alive sincerely for the purpose of ‘protecting’ the public. No, I believe that Lance knew exactly what he was doing, and didn’t care. This makes him one of the biggest sports villains of my lifetime.
Barry Bonds
I don’t have anything very funny to say about Barry Bonds, which is fitting because nothing he ever did or said was close to funny.
Barry Bonds, perhaps the most obvious cheater of the 21st century, should be considered one of the best (or worst) villains of our era because to put it simply, he didn’t give a fuck. While the ex-Giants slugger did sign off on an autobiographical documentary , he otherwise appeared to make no attempt whatsoever to win over–or even engage with–the media and his fans. Bonds takes the idea of “knowing and not caring” to a new level because he was actively involved in his defense against performance enhancing drugs during the peak of his Home Run conquest as a ballplayer. While Bonds may have broken the all-time record for HR’s, it’s a) not even a question whether or not he cheated in order to do it, and b) likely that he won’t ever be voted into the Baseball Hall of Fame.
Barry Bonds is such a villain that no team would sign him after he left the Giants in 2007. He was too controversial a character for any professional team to seriously consider investing in him. That’s how much people hated him. Now that, ladies and gentlemen, is a villain.
Roger Clemens
Clemens appears at Fenway Park last week to have his number retired as a Red Sox. Ted Williams simultaneously rolls over his his frozen grave.
The Rocket is a special type of villain, because he remained evil throughout his career and afterwards, for separate reasons. Many years ago, there was an article written that covered Clemens’ wrongdoings up until 2001, so I won’t bore you with too much information. Instead, I’ll sum up all of the shady things Clemens has done since he entered the league.
-Did Roger Clemens leave the Boston Red Sox in 1996 to sign with a weak Blue Jays team for more money, hire a personal trainer to get into better shape, and not acknowledge Boston fans in any way when he departed? Yes, he did.
-Did Clemens then leave the aforementioned Blue Jays to sign with the Yankees to chase championships in a LeBron James-like fashion? Yes, he did.
-In the 2000 World Series, did Clemens throw a piece of a bat at Mike Piazza for no apparent reason, and defend his actions by claiming that he thought it was the ball he was throwing directly at a player for no reason, but NOT the bat? Of course.
–Before he achieved his 300th career victory, did Roger Clemens wear a patch on his glove commemorating the milestone, only to lose the game to his former team? 100%.
-Did Roger announce his retirement before the 2003 season, and make his rounds in visiting ballparks like Mariano Rivera and Derek Jeter, only to return to baseball–but for a different franchise? Did Clemens pull the exact same move 3 years later? Next Question.
-Was the fireballer from Texas explicitly implicated in using performance-enhancing drugs, yet VEHEMENTLY denied it for years and years, thus getting him into further trouble with the law? You get the idea.
Roger Clemens, in the words of MC Ren, is a “ruthless gangsta, definition: villain”. Nobody that I can think of was hated by the public for such a long period time, and he managed to attain this while going from one heinous act to another. The good news for Clemens? He’s only 52 years old. He has plenty of time to engage in more shady business.
Bill Belichick
Coach Belichick actin’ all friendly and such with his ex-Quarterback, Drew Bledsoe.
Me to my fellow Patriots friend Brian: You know we’re going to have to include Belichick in the villain article, right?
Brian: What? Why??
Me: I mean, people have plenty of reason not to like him. He got caught taping other people’s practices, he may have known about some of the illegal activities Aaron Hernandez was getting into–plus his press conference after Hernandez’s arrest was awful–and he walked out of the stadium without shaking Tom Coughlin’s hand after the 18-1 game.
My friend Ben, also a Patriots fan: Also, he’s just kind of a dick.
That’s right, folks. You heard it here first–Patriots fans admit Belichick is sort of a scumbag! It would biased of me to speak otherwise. I think that deep down, everyone in New England sees Belichick for kind of an evil dude, but is willing to look past it because he is such an intelligent individual. Belichick is more unlikable than he is a villain to be honest; he hasn’t broken the law, hasn’t lied to a grand jury (which I know is also against the law, but I figured I’d clarify because Clemens was acquitted of this charge). However, the combination of success and arrogancy is what makes Belichick the NFL’s most hated individual (other than the impossibly evil Roger Goodell).
Going through Chuck Klosterman’s diagram of a villain, Belichick certainly appears to know the most. His draft choices, play calling and roster moves are unethical to say the least, and he continuously lets his best players walk to save salary cap space. But Belichick doesn’t care; it’s all about being successful at the end of the day. Perhaps a Patriots hater’s favorite moment in the past decade was seeing Brady and Co. get stopped on 4th and 2 on their own 28 yard line with time running out in the 4th quarter against the then-undefeated Indianapolis Colts. People loved it because not only did the Patriots lose in gut-wrenching fashion, they lost because of Belichick’s strategic cockiness.
Whether or not you think Belichick’s “bedside manor” in press conference is funny, smart, rude, or horrible, its obvious that Belichick has done very little to connect with the media and fans. This is fine for supporters of the Patriots, because they understand that winning is more important in a case like this, but it’s easy to see why his poor reputation stems from his lack of tact in public. Plus, everyone hates how damn good Belichick and the Pats are, even with their best players are sidelined with injury. GO PATS!!
A Villainous Digression: Alex Rodriguez is Not a Villain
A-Rod makes an appearance at a Madonna concert with a woman who he dumped moments later for Madonna.
While A-Rod may be one of the most hated athletes (not only this century, but all time?), I can’t classify him as a villain. While he may have one of the qualifying attributes (maintaining innocence for using PED’s over a long period of time, regardless of the countless evidence to the contrary), he fails to register on any villainous scale because he cares too much. All his career, Rodriguez has tinkered with his public perception–especially once he joined the New York Yankees in 2004–in order to “appear” like a nice, fun-loving guy. Now, I’m no body language expert, but I can tell the difference between Derek Jeter being a leader and A-Rod pretending to be one. I can’t speak for Yankees fans, but I think this is the root of their problem with their highly overpaid 3rd basemen–he has always tried to act like he is a good teammate and person, but acting simply isn’t enough.
By holding on to his idea of what Alex Rodriguez means to the general public, A-Rod has been unable to embrace the prospect of being one of Baseball’s biggest villains. While I won’t be condoning this type of behavior any time soon, A-Rod’s problem is that he wants other people to like him so much that he can’t even bring himself to understand how others might perceive some of his actions as wrong, or evil. Alex is no villain, just a phony.
Kobe Bryant
Bryant welcomes Jeremy Lin to the Lakers while appearing in his self-mandated uniform of all-black.
The Black Mamba is a curious case, because he is actually a very nuanced type of villain. He started out just a competitive young guy, with a common upbeat energy. Winning championships brought him to a mental state from which he could not return (“I’m the best, this is my team”). His subsequent issues with Phil Jackson and Shaq, amongst rape allegations took his villainy to another level.Without shedding too much light on the events take took place in Eagle, Colorado all those years ago, it’s safe to conclude that this was a pivotal moment in Kobe’s villainous career. Once Kobe was charged for statutory rape–and then acquitted–he became one of the most hated players in the NBA. The chip on Bryant’s shoulder grew to an astronomical size, and he fully embraced his role as the anti-hero. In his formative years, Kobe has taken to wearing black at all times (perhaps to promote his clothing line? probably not…) to further embrace his persona. Someone with cultural awareness as high as Kobe’s is smart enough to understand that the color black is most associated with being The Bad Guy, and Bryant has passed the test of evil with flying colors (pun very much intended).
Last season, as he was maimed by injuries, wearing black at the end of the bench, Kobe endured being the last big star remaining on the Lakers. He’s now the veteran that players and fans alike love to fear or to hate. You want to respect him, he wants you to respect him, but if he knows you respect him, then he considers you to be a peasant. It defies all the normal conventions of respect. Respect is usually returned by gratitude. So you end up saying, “fine, fuck you, Kobe” which in the end is what he really wants.I think this thought process (which we’ve projected on to Kobe) is what makes him a villain, but also a fierce competitor. While it’s also important note that he’s never (successfully anyway) “teamed up” with another superstar in order to win a championship–at least not in the artificial way that it seems to happen these days–,one should also keep in mind that Kobe enjoys being The Guy. In the Mamba’s mind, the more negative spin on his persona, the better.
Tony Stewart
While the jury is still out on Mr. Stewart, try your best not to let this photo sway you in either direction.
While criminal charges don’t appear to be coming, Tony Stewart killed a fellow driver, Kevin Ward Jr., after he spun the guy out of the race. Did Kevin Ward walk dangerously out on to the race track after he was fishtailed by Stewart? Yes. Will this exempt Tony Stewart from criminal charges? Yes. Does it make Stewart less of a villain? NO!
I know it’s easy to sit back and say he could have avoided him, but my humble opinion is that Kevin Ward’s death was no accident . Both men are at fault, but once Ward wandered out on the track, only one man could change what happened next. Stewart is a really good driver. As in good enough to avoid Kevin Ward.
Also, I don’t follow NASCAR, but everyone says Stewart is an asshole. This doesn’t help his reputation, accident or not.
Ben Roethlisberger
Unfortunately–for the legal system and the NFL’s credibility–this was the closest Roethlisberger ever came to wearing a prison uniform.
I think what makes Big Ben such a bad guy is that he committed one of the worst crimes known to man, got off relatively unscathed, served a 6-game suspension (6 games!!!), and then went back to living his life like nothing happened. In the case of “Ben” (as broadcasters so amicably refer to him), I find it loathsome that he did little to maintain his innocence. Roethlisberger has been rumoured to have sexually assaulted a woman not once but twice (!!) and he’s still playing in the NFL. To me, Roethlisberger is one of the biggest villains on this list because he seems to be so under-the-radar. Perhaps this is because his skills and numbers have declined (stats may say otherwise but Pittsburgh has tended to pass the football more and more often, inflating passing averages for Big Ben), or that his team hasn’t made the playoffs in a couple of years, but all I have to say is the Mike Vick got suspended and went to jail for abusing not human beings, and Big Ben sat out 6 weeks for abusing a real-life human being.
Rick Pitino and John Calipari: The Most Interesting Villains in the World
Vito Corleone doing his best Rick Pitino impression.
If a big part of being a villain is looking the part, Rick Pitino fits the bill. His white suits, slicked back hair, and overall demeanor is straight up frightening. Oh, and before I forget, he had an affair with a woman in a restaurant after closing (the owner left him the keys so he could lock up after). Pitino paid her 3k to get an abortion as a result of their sexy times, but refused to give her the cars and college tuition for her kids that she demanded. As a victim of extortion, Pitino not only came clean about the affair, but provided some great detail about the deed. According Rick Pitino’s wikipedia page, under oath, “Pitino down played the pair’s sexual escapade. The complete act took, the coach testified, ‘No more than 15 seconds’”. Great stuff.
Pitino’s recruiting violations are not really notable, at least ones he’s been punished for. As an assistant coach for the University Hawaii in the 70s, Pitino was cited for handing out McDonalds coupons to his players, buying their plane tickets back to the continental U.S., and providing players with used cars (cause Hawaii’s public transportation system sucks). This violations pale in comparison to Coach Cal’s, but they are not exactly ethical.
Finally, I have to add that Rick Pitino’s tenure as the Boston Celtics coach adds to his villain legacy. This press conference sealed his fate in Boston Celtics fans’ eyes as an a**hole. You can’t call the legendary Larry Bird, Kevin McHale, and Robert Parrish ‘gray and old’ and expect to stick around long. Pitino cemented himself as a villain in Boston in just 15 seconds 😉
I assume that if you rub Coach Cal’s head enough, money starts to come out of his ears.
John Calipari is perhaps the toughest of characters to categorize. In my summation, Coach Cal is one of two things: he is working so hard to build his public persona as a go-getting, smooth-talking guy because he so desperately wants to cover up his bad side, or his go-getting, smooth-talking attitude forces people to presume he is a bad guy because of how we label successful people like him in society. Take a look at these undisputed facts:
-Every University John Calipari has left has been under direct violation of NCAA grades/recruiting policy, and all wins under his tenure have been vacated.
-John Calipari openly talks about how his goal as a college coach is to prepare players for the NBA, as opposed to finishing school and getting an education.
-John Calipari is set to make somewhere around $7 Million each year from now until 2021.
-For the most part, every player who has ever played for John Calipari adores him.
Does this mean that Kentucky’s Head Ball Coach is using his players’ talent alone to move up the ladder of success, while callously overlooking NCAA restrictions on recruitment? Or does he genuinely care about his players, and will do whatever it takes to ensure that they live successful, prolonged professional careers in the NBA which they can’t legally attain at the age of 18?
There are two sides to any story, and in the case of Calipari, both arguments are extremely compelling. Perhaps we will have to wait for the inevitable Kentucky recruiting violations to surface after he leaves his current school, but until now Coach Cal’s status as “villain” will have to remain up to the people to decide.
Honorable Mentions: Nick Saban (too similar to Belichick), Rasheed Wallace (kind of the man), Skip Bayless (too obvious) , Stephen A. Smith (ditto), Any ESPN Personality (too boring), Mike Vick (America “forgave” him, I guess…)
Too Evil to Write a Think Piece About: Roger Goodell, Donald Sterling, Jerry Sandusky, Aaron Hernandez (yes, we’ve grouped Roger Goodell with a racist, pedophile, and murderer)